Back when “emo” wasn’t a four-letter word, Sideshow played some of the best posthardcore (punk) rock around.
Bass player/vocalist Bernie McGinn runs (ran?) Caulfield Records, which released most of the Sideshow recordings. I don’t know much about Sideshow other than that they introduced me to Caulfield Records, which was hugely influential for the Midwest Indie Rock scene, releasing a string of criminally under-appreciated records. However, the great “Built on a weak spot” had a really nice post with much more info and some additional tracks from various other Sideshow releases a while ago. So you should definitely go there and get what you are missing here.
Sideshow has a very unique and interesting sound (otherwise I would not post it here), but they are also very much a child of their time (which for me being musically imprinted on late 80s - early 90s bands is also a good thing). To me the obvious comparisons for Sideshow are Rain (La Vache Qui Rit), Rites of Spring, One Last Wish, Policy of 3 and a couple of other bands that embody the early Dischord sound.
In any case, this, their first LP, does neither sound dated nor like an imitation of any of the aforementioned bands. Their sound is a bit less angular, and if anything I enjoy them much more than say Rites of Spring, which get all the credit as pioneers of the genre.
UPDATE: Now with more Lip read confusion (their 2nd full length)


